Nat Coombs: Sucking For Luck
This week Nat looks at the intriguing story behind which NFL team may end up with consensus No. 1 draft pick Andrew Luck from Stanford.
As usual, there are a number of interesting narratives in the NFL this season. Is there anyone that can deal with the Packers in the NFC – or indeed the whole league for that matter? What has gone wrong with the self proclaimed Dream Team in Philly?
I’m not even gonna mention Tebow – but if you’re interested in the most white hot phenom in sports right now you can read my last column on the Denver QB right here.
But perhaps the most intriguing storyline of all is the fact that a significant number of fans, supporting dead in the water teams, are willing them to lose as many games as possible, to enable them to have the best chance of landing the Number One Draft Pick. Or as it’s become commonly known – SuckForLuck.
Andrew Luck, the Stanford QB, is the designated Number 1 Pick in the 2012 Draft according to every draft expert in the entire world. Even the late, great Al Davis – known for his erratic choices in his latter years that seemingly ranked speed in a player as more important than all other attributes combined – would have grabbed Luck with both hands, should his Raiders have the option.

Luck has already been anointed as the NFL’s next “Great Quarterback” and is expected to vault into the elite class of Brady, Manning, Brees and Rodgers within a short time of turning pro (which will be a year late as he actually turned down the chance to declare for nthe NFL darft last season). He’s the guy you can build a franchise round, they say. Here’s the real deal.
He has the intelligence, maturity, throwing technique (Tebow’s Achilles Heel, of course) and understanding of a pro-style offense (supposedly Cam Newton’s main issue, though he’s not faring too badly these days) not seen for a long time at that age. Aaron Rodgers, Philip Rivers & Co. didn’t even get close to this kind of universal acclaim when they came out. His reputation precedes him so powerfully, that you’ll find NFL fans the world over who haven’t even seen Luck take a snap that’ll tell you he’s the best quarterback available in the Draft since Peyton Manning. The best College QB I’ve ever seen, they’ll assure you.
And as for the team owners, remember that the Number One pick is much sexier now that the re-aligned Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) means it’s not as huge a financial risk as it used to be. So the chance of busting out an Al Davis / JaMarcus Russell style over-reach is less painful. Taking a QB – as opposed to a blindside tackle who you can at least farm out to the other side, and then to guard if he doesn’t work out – is less risky than it used to be.
Yep – whichever way you cut it, Andrew Luck is the future, and teams are falling over themselves to get him; leading to all manner of conspiracy theories that teams are deliberately tanking to stand a shot of getting him. Ironically, I heard more than a few wise heads suggest at the start of the season that Jim Harbaugh, the 49ers’ Head Coach and Luck’s former coach at Stanford, started the hitherto hapless Alex Smith at QB to ensure San Fran would be in the cellar. Smith seems to be having the last laugh there – as the Niners have just clinched the NFC West. Although a 64-2 NFC Championship blowout is on the cards for them.
Of course, there is one team that no one saw in the box seat for Luck, and the fact that they seem to be storming their way to a perfect 0-16 record, thus guaranteeing the Number One pick, poses some real conundrums for Bill Polian and his board in Indianapolis. What was previously unthinkable – namely drafting Luck and trading Peyton Manning – is an idea gaining momentum in various quarters of the media. The extent of Manning’s neck injury is unclear and even if he comes back fighting fit and playing to the same level, he’s got perhaps four more years left in him. So do they take Luck, let him sit and learn from Manning? … thus creating the most expensive back up in the history of the game, but also ensuring a fluent succession with a guy capable of running the table for the next 10 to12 years – or do they gamble, trade Manning and start their future right now?
Another variable is for them to draft Luck, let him sit for a while, and then trade him to a desperate suitor (as the Eagles did with Kevin Kolb). But the Eagles had Michael Vick by then – not a spring chicken but younger than Manning – and they clearly had a plan grabbing Vince Young, the logical Number 2 to Vick in that style of offense.
So many options – and that’s just the Colts. The Seahawks, Browns, Jaguars are all in the running and they really need a QB so they could well trade up if they don’t end up with the worst record. And let’s face it gang, we could do with some crazy horse-trading on Draft Day after the vanilla CBA induced inertia of this year.
Yet there is one aspect that isn’t being considered at all. It’s all very well Sucking for Luck. But what if Luck Sucks? We’re all assuming he’s going to be great. What if he’s not?
Remember Ryan Leaf? Selected second overall behind Peyton Manning in the 1998 draft – and many scouts couldn’t decide between them. Doesn’t matter who goes 1 or 2, they said. Both these guys are going to have All-Pro Careers. These weren’t mid-second round developmental players that may end up with an OK career. These were NFL locks. Yet Leaf turned out to be one of the biggest draft busts of all time.
And out of the most recent drafts, and number one QB picks, the aformentioned JaMarcus is now out of the league and out of most people’s minds. Of other recent highly-rated QB recruits, Matt Stafford is good but injury prone and Sam Bradford is having a torrid time in St. Louis after a promising start. None of those guys may have been dead certs in precisely the same way that people say Luck is going to be, but the principle remains. These are golden boys in the second golden age of the QB. And none of them look like being another Brady (a sixth round pick BTW) or Manning.
In some respects, you sense that the Colts hierarchy hope they can land a few wins just to avoid the complex decision. Either way, whoever does end up with Andrew Luck would do well to remember that they don’t necessarily have a sure thing. Somewhere, Joey Harrington is reading this, and nodding sagely.
AMERICAN FOOTBALL ON ESPN AMERICA
The NCAA College Football season on ESPN America
Click here for details and latest TV schedules, etc.
Viewers in Europe can also watch the NFL season and ESPN’s Monday Night Football
Click here for more details and latest TV schedules, etc.
While viewers in the UK and Ireland can tune in to NFL Monday Night Football on ESPN.
Click here for more details.
You can also follow ESPN America on Twitter or Facebook to get the latest updates on TV scheduling, competitions, blogs, etc.
Click here to enter our Monday Night Football and other prize competitions.
NAT COOMBS is a writer and broadcaster who hosts the chat show Talk of The Terrace on our partner channel ESPN, and both NFL & MLB coverage on BBC Radio Five Live. He also anchors the US sports podcast Americarnage. Follow Nat on Twitter
Of course, his all American good looks and virtuous, “good guy” demeanor – the latter inspired by his deep seated, and often ridiculed religious faith – have helped fan the flames of celebrity. Kids want to be like him. Parents want their sons to grow up like him and hope their daughters grow up to marry someone like him.
So there’s time for Tebow, yet. Because things change in the NFL! We could all be sitting here in 18 months time, wondering where the next Tebow is coming from, and chuckling at the days when we used to recognize arm strength – traditionally way over valued (JaMarcus Russell, anyone) as far more important than anything else.




























