Nat Coombs: Deal or No Deal?
NAT COOMBS is a writer and broadcaster who hosts the chat show Talk of The Terrace on our partner channel ESPN, and both NFL & MLB coverage on BBC Radio Five Live. He also anchors the US sports podcast Americarnage and is a regular guest on ESPN Radio’s Fantasy Baseball Podcast.
Arizona Cardinals star receiver Larry Fitzgerald’s new deal – which could be worth up to $120 million dollars over 8 years – has raised more than a few eyebrows, mine included, though I wish I was able to actually move them without using my finger, or by using tape.
Now we’re not talking the kind of jaw-drop shock that, say, casting Zach Galifianakis as Batman would generate. Though if we got David Lynch to direct, and cast Steve Guttenberg as Robin, we may just have an Oscar on our hands.
No-one could begrudge Fitzgerald the money – he’s the consummate contemporary NFL pro – explosive power, superhero size, nearly flawless dexterity all bound together by a 1000 watt smile that wouldn’t look out of place on the campaign trail (you heard it here first: the Democratic nomination for the 2024 President of the United States is Larry Darnell Fitzgerald).

HAND-SOME REWARD: Larry receives a mega-deal contract.
Yep, Everybody Loves Larry, and his loyalty to the Arizona Cardinals – whose post Super Bowl XLIII hangover is second in the list of greatest hangovers ever, just behind every morning of Motley Crue’s life – is to be heartily admired.
But it’s still a significant deal for a receiver – and in fact, makes him tied with Richard Seymour as the fifth highest paid player of any position in the NFL – a list that is typically populated by two types of player: defensive linemen and, of course, quarterbacks.
Indeed, in this year’s Best Paid List, the top four above Fitz are all QBs, including the Rams’ Sam Bradford who was the lucky final recipient of the megabucks deals given to Number One draft picks prior to the new CBA and rookie salary cap getting struck.
You see, when it comes to spending money in the NFL, the following law seems to apply:
Spend your money on the QB, the guy who protects the QB, or the guy who tries to kill the other team’s QB.
The Colts’ President Bill Polian – who recently made four-time League MVP Peyton Manning the best-paid player in the NFL, is among the shrewdest operators in the league and reinforces this view, saying that other positional players are interchangeable.
This strategy is borne out in the Draft too, where wide receivers are always among the riskiest players to take during the early rounds. That logic is fairly sound: if a tackle doesn’t work out, he can be switched to a guard. If a WR doesn’t work out, well, there’s always Arena Football. Or TNA Wrestling.
Fitz isn’t a spring chicken either, with the 2011 season representing his seventh in the league. There’s no doubt as to his peak physical conditioning, and his professionalism will buy him an extra year or two, but this is a League where pace is ever increasing. The fact that in the NFL the passing game is once again gaining increasing significance (after the early noughties where the running back was King) may make this deal seem like a smart play, but remember that this inevitably means that the play of defensive backs will continue to become sharper and sharper. Reckon it’s any coincidence some of the biggest superstars in the NFL right now are shut-down corners Darrelle Revis and Nnamdi Asomugha? No, didn’t think so.
There is, of course, the argument that Fitzgerald has been rewarded for his loyalty Derek Jeter-style – in so far as the exactitude of the deal in financial terms doesn’t stack up, but it’s the contractual equivalent of back pay for years of service where the original deal wasn’t fair to the player. (To use a cultural parallel, take Martin Scorsese’s Academy Award for Gangs of New York, which was given more for the awards he should have won in the past but didn’t, rather than that specific movie.)
Furthermore, the Cardinals knew that letting Fitz go would have been disastrous – not just for the immediate negative impact on the quality of the team but the message it would send out to other existing stars, potential free agents and future draft picks.
Time will tell if the deal stacks up. While I ponder it further – and also consider whether I’ll ever write a column, which includes the statement “The Punter is King”, why don’t you browse my Top Five NFL Deals Ever. Not surprisingly, it doesn’t include Ryan Leaf.
TOP FIVE NFL DEALS EVER

ONE THAT GOT AWAY: Jerry Rice could have been a Cowboy!
5. 49ers trade up to get Jerry Rice
Unbelievable as it may seem, Mississippi Valley’s Rice wasn’t that highly rated coming into the 1985 NFL draft. He had a 4.59 40 Yard Time – which was both unrepresentative of his true speed, and (other than the widely held belief in the MLB during the early 80’s that moustaches “make you hit the ball harder”) the biggest red herring in sporting history as coaching staffs across the league sniffed at his mediocre time.
As Rice dropped down the draft board, the Cowboys had their eye on him at #17 but at the last minute the late, great Bill Walsh struck a momentous deal with the New England Patriots, who had pick #16.
The 49ers gave up a lot (at the time): their first two picks (and swapped third round picks) but ended up with the best receiver the game has ever seen. Case closed.
4. Drew Brees to New Orleans Saints
In 2006, after Drew Brees wanted out of San Diego, feeling that the offer of a 5-year $50 million dollar was too low on the “guara” (guaranteed money within a contract). He had two options. Going to the promising Miami Dolphins (contenders for the playoffs under head coach Nick Saban) or to New Orleans, a franchise in disarray after Hurricane Katrina, with an untested first year head coach in Sean Payton.
Surprisingly, Brees took the Saints’ 6-year $60 million dollar offer (similar to the Chargers deal but with a much bigger portion of ‘guara’) and three seasons later the pair took New Orleans to the Promised Land. Clearly Philip Rivers has now emerged as a terrific young quarterback, but would the (14-2) 2006 Chargers, knocked out in the AFC Divisional Round in the playoffs, have gone all the way with Brees at the helm? Probably.

PASSED OVER: Brett Favre soared in his post-Falcon days.
3. Brett Favre to the Packers
It’s somewhat appropriate that former Falcons’ head coach Jerry Glanville likes wearing black so much, seeing as he was responsible for one of the blackest days in Falcons’ history. For Jerry was the man who traded away Brett Favre. Much to Jerry’s chagrin, Atlanta had drafted Favre in the second round of the 1991 Draft (33rd overall pick) and he offloaded the future Hall of Famer to the Green Bay Packers for a first round draft pick in the 1992 Draft.
And with the 19th overall pick, the Falcons drafted Favre’s Southern Mississippi team-mate and running back Tony Smith. Yep, that Tony Smith, who played for three seasons and promptly retired. To be fair he did average a touchdown a season (starting in just six games). Favre – as we all know and Falcons’ fans keep trying to forget – went on to become one the greatest players the game has ever seen (despite having Lorenzo as a middle name).
2. Johnny Unitas to the Baltimore Colts
In 1955, Unitas was drafted in the ninth round by the Pittsburgh Steelers, but they released him before the start of the season. Head coach Walt Kiesling had him ranked fourth on the depth chart … as you do, with one of the all-time greats.
Drifting around semi-pro ball and working in construction to support his family, Unitas went along with his cousin for a trial at the Baltimore Colts. Their head coach, the remarkably named Weeb Ewbank saw a spark in Unitas that prompted him to take a chance, and offered him a slot on the roster as a backup. An injury to Colts’ starter George Shaw gave Unitas his shot and three Championships (including Super Bowl V) and a Hall of Fame career later, the legend of Johnny U lives on (everywhere except in Steeltown)

COWBOYS & ALIENS?: Herschel's trade was out of this world.
1. Herschel Walker to the Vikings
The fact that this deal is often referred to HWT (the Herschel Walker Trade) – or as I prefer to call it “The Great Train Robbery” – ossibly tells you all you need to know. In 1989 new Cowboys’ head coach Jimmy Johnson did the unthinkable and traded away his star running back Herschel Walker, virtually the only Cowboy with any significant talent. In return from the Minnesota Vikings, America’s Team received five starters plus three first round draft picks and three second round draft picks, which they subsequently used to bring in the likes of Emmitt Smith and Darren Woodson, and a host of others/ This almost complete team rebuilding courtesy of the ‘HWT’ proved to be the foundation for the Cowboys’ 1990s dynasty, and three Super Bowl wins.
Walker didn’t post a single 1000+ yard seasons in his time at Minnesota and left in 1991 making him this deal the Poster Child for Buy Low, Sell High. After dabbling with Olympic Bobsleigh and MMA, he has recently hinted at a return to the NFL (he’s currently 49) so watch this space. What are the chances that the Vikes could use him alongside Adrian Peterson?
LIVE SPORT ON ESPN AMERICA
Viewers in Europe can watch the new NFL season and ESPN’s Monday Night Football – Click here for more details.
While viewers in the UK and Irleand can tune in to the NFL on ESPN. Click here for more details.
The new NCAA College Football season is also available throughout Europe on ESPN America – click here for details.
NAT COOMBS is a writer and broadcaster who hosts the chat show Talk of The Terrace on our partner channel ESPN, and both NFL & MLB coverage on BBC Radio Five Live. He also anchors the US sports podcast Americarnage and is a regular guest on ESPN Radio’s 
























NAT COOMBS is a TV presenter, comedian, producer and writer. He anchors Major League Baseball & NFL Live on BBC Five Live Sports Xtra and is a regular guest on TV and radio shows, adding his leftfield insight and unique take on the world of sports and their pop culture crossover. He writes for a range of national newspapers and websites, including this blog for ESPN America. 








